At 507 South Street in Key West, The Lobster Shack is a small, casual seafood spot near the Southernmost Point buoy. Its menu centers on lobster rolls, with the Key West version pairing warm butter and a hint of Key lime on a toasted roll. You can also choose a traditional or spicy Diablo roll, lobster bisque, or lobster grilled cheese. Seating is limited, so this works best for a quick lunch or takeaway rather than a long, roomy meal.
A small seafood stop on South Street
The Lobster Shack is at 507 South Street, close to the Southernmost Point buoy. The compact restaurant has a casual setup, with limited indoor seating, counter stools and a picnic table outside. There is also a to-go window, so you can pick up lunch instead of waiting for a seat.
The focused menu makes this a good stop when you want lobster without planning a long meal. The restaurant serves lunch Tuesday through Saturday, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. It is closed on Monday and Sunday.
Which lobster roll to order
The Key West lobster roll is the signature choice: lobster with warm butter and a touch of fresh Key lime, served in a toasted roll. For a more traditional style, order the New England roll. The Diablo version brings heat with Sriracha and jalapeños.
If you want something beyond a roll, the lobster grilled cheese combines lobster with toasted bread; bacon and jalapeños are among the reported add-ons. Lobster bisque is another option. The menu also includes shrimp, including coconut shrimp, for anyone in your group who wants a change from lobster.
Plan for a quick, casual lunch
Service is described as quick, and the small dining area can fill up. Going on a weekday or outside busy periods can help you avoid a longer wait. You can eat at the picnic table or take your order to go.
The food is served simply: a lobster roll may come with chips and a pickle. The limited seating and focused menu suit a quick stop after visiting the nearby Southernmost Point. If you are looking for a spacious dining room or a broad menu, this is probably not the right place.
Häufige Fragen
Where is The Lobster Shack in Key West?
It is at 507 South Street, near the Southernmost Point buoy.
What should I order at The Lobster Shack?
The Key West lobster roll comes with warm butter and a hint of Key lime. Other choices include the traditional and Diablo lobster rolls, lobster bisque and lobster grilled cheese.
When is The Lobster Shack open?
It is open Tuesday through Saturday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. It is closed on Monday and Sunday.
Is there indoor seating?
Yes, but the restaurant is small, with limited indoor seating, counter stools and an outdoor picnic table. A to-go window is also available.
